South Korea warns Japan of coalition to highlight wartime abuses

South Korea deputy trade minister Kim Seung-ho arrives for the General Council meeting where the worsening trade and diplomatic dispute between South Korea and Japan will be raised at the World Trade Organization (WTO) in Geneva, Switzerland, 24 July 2019 (Photo: Reuters/Denis Balibouse). Sketched by the Pan Pacific Agency.

SEOUL, JUl 24, 2020, Bloomberg. South Korea warned that Japan risked reigniting tensions if it didn’t acknowledge past forced labor abuses, saying Seoul was prepared to build a regional coalition to hold Tokyo to account for its colonial behavior, The Japan Times reported.

South Korean Culture Minister Park Yang-woo said in an interview Thursday that international criticism would be “unavoidable” without public recognition by Japan that human rights abuses occurred at the Hashima island industrial site off the coast of Nagasaki. While Park declined to elaborate on the countries South Korea would lobby for support, China has long been among the most vocal critics of Japanese efforts to explain its wartime past.

“If Japan keeps distorting the history, Korea will respond with other Asian countries with other issues, as well,” Park said in Seoul. “We will also rightfully support those countries that face circumstances similar to what we are facing right now.”

Any South Korean appeal to Beijing could concern Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, who has seen his rapprochement efforts with Chinese President Xi Jinping stall amid the coronavirus outbreak and disagreements over territorial claims and Hong Kong. It could also complicate U.S. efforts to bolster its Asian alliance network to counter China’s rise.

The decades-old forced labor dispute has re-emerged since Japan opened an information center in Tokyo last month that included materials suggesting conscripted workers at Hashima island were paid and well treated. South Korea considers the display a breach of its 2015 agreement to support Japan’s ultimately successful bid to get the 19th century industrial incubator listed as an UNESCO World Heritage Site. They want Tokyo to change the exhibit or have the heritage status rescinded.

The disagreement could undermine a truce that ended an unprecedented trade war between the two U.S. allies last year after South Korean courts upheld a series of forced labor claims against Japanese companies. The courts could as soon as next month rule on whether to liquidate corporate assets to compensate victims, something Tokyo would consider an escalation.

Shigeki Takizaki, a senior Foreign Ministry official, dismissed complaints about the Hashima exhibit as “unacceptable” in a call with his South Korean counterpart last month. Japan will abide by its commitment to United Nations agencies, said Takizaki, the ministry’s director general of Asian and Oceanian Affairs.

Asked Wednesday to further explain Japan’s response, the Foreign Ministry in Tokyo said it wasn’t prepared to comment immediately. The Japanese Embassy in Seoul didn’t respond to a request for comment about Park’s remarks Thursday, a Japanese public holiday.

“We will continue to endlessly discuss this issue, and we believe that this will also have an effect with our future exchanges with Japan, as well,” Park said Thursday. “To deny that is also being dishonest.”

The walled 6.3-hectare Hashima island — sometimes called Battleship Island — was a site of undersea coal mining in the 1880s and became a symbol of both Japan’s rapid Meiji modernization era and its subsequent colonial abuses. The use of hundreds of thousands of laborers from China, South Korea and other areas occupied between 1895 and 1945 remains a contentious issue with many of the country’s neighbors, with some surviving victims still pursuing claims.

Although most South Koreans believe Japan hasn’t sufficiently apologized for its actions, many Japanese see past statements of regret as sufficient. Japan has taken issue with South Korea’s description of the laborers as forced, preferring “former civilian workers from the Korean Peninsula.”

South Korea endorsed Hashima’s inclusion on the heritage list after Japan agreed to convey an “an understanding of the full history of each site.” But the information center in Tokyo’s Shinjuku district makes no mention of forced labor, instead citing one ethnic Korean and former Hashima resident saying there was no discrimination. The center also displays a wage stub of a conscripted worker from Taiwan, suggesting that such laborers had received payment.

“It depicts the situation as if South Koreans had voluntarily done this, as if there was nothing forced in the process,” Park said. “This is stating an outright lie. This is a serious distortion of history, and also a violation of what Japan had initially promised.”

Share it

Exclusive: Beyond the Covid-19 world's coverage